I had a 3rd grade homeroom that was struggling a little bit. They had a long term sub and a lot of kiddos who just need a lot of extra love and structure. There's a group of 5 in particular who were constantly finding themselves involved in drama with one another. Their reading teacher told me that she was spending about 15 minutes every day debriefing with them after lunch/recess before she was able to actually teach them.
My attempt to help with this problem was to have a mini lunch-bunch group to finish out the end of the year with the drama llamas. This is a group of bright, highly-verbal, and fun students - 4 girls and 1 boy - and I knew they were going to be a hoot. I love lunch bunches because the teachers never have any problem with me pulling kids during lunch, but it's hard to do a lot of activities when there are trays of food being eaten on the table, so I sometimes find them to be a challenge. Here's a breakdown of what we did together.
- Explain purpose of group
- Discuss group rules and goals
- Play game to continue to establish norms
- ***They knew pretty much immediately why they were all in the group. While I'm not sure that I had investment for change right away, they could all acknowledge that they were having these problems.
- Read Drama Llama. (I love this book! It's right in the 3rd grade sweet spot in my opinion. It's short and the accompanying activity pages are grade B, but it's such a great little intro to the topic)
- Ask students why the character Lucy was stirring up drama (to get attention, because she thought it would make her popular, she didn’t want to be boring)
- Write “small minds talk about people, average minds talk about events, great minds talk about ideas” on board, or show poster of the quote. Discuss its meaning. Give concrete examples (i.e. if all Kaya ever talks about is other people, will I think she’s cool and interesting? No! I may think she’s boring if that’s all she talks about, because then I’ll think she has nothing else in her brain”)
- Students brainstorm ideas of different things they can talk about at lunch and recess other than other people. Put on quote/poster. Share out on some of them and challenge students to utilize them in the next week.
- Read Trouble Talk, discuss.
- Introduce THINK acronym and ask how it connects to the story.
- Do THINK card sorts (I used the sets I made for this lesson before I found a way better whole class option). We discussed each THINK rule, then they took turns reading examples and we decided together if the examples broke or followed the rule.
- Around the table, each student identifies which THINK rule they need to work on. Unsurprisingly, almost of of the students in this group identified "necessary" as the rule they struggle with the most, though a couple also mentioned "true"
- Ask students what they know about invitations to things (it’s when someone invites you to come, you can go or not go, etc.)
- Write “You don’t have to attend every argument you’re invited to” on the board.
- Explain that every time someone says something that bothers you, it could be like an invitation to an argument (or like a hook!). You don’t have to attend – you don’t have to participate – you can choose to let it go.
- Using little blank cards from the Target dollar spot, I wrote the four kiddos at our last session each an "invitation" to participate in some 3rd grade drama. They took turns opening them, reading them aloud, and then talking through what they would do. Scenarios were: friend insulted your hair, someone said one of your good friends was talking about you behind your back, you overheard a teacher say one of your classmates was failing, and someone suggested a classmate has been really bossy lately.